The Cost of One More Item
The product, document or result is one part of the story. Inspect the source record and the decision behind a specific revision.
Bennett Cho
Third-year BS student
FBM 210 · Menu Contribution
Adviser: Dr. Colin Adebayo
Original simulated teaching case

The question and the learner
Bennett Cho's first version of a food-enterprise concept included one more menu item because the proposed selling price would be higher. It seemed an obvious improvement until the class separated the additional revenue from the additional material cost. In Menu Contribution, Dr. Colin Adebayo asked Bennett to keep the scenario small enough that every assumption could be inspected. The question became whether a seventy-five-cent price increase covered a ninety-cent addition to the modeled materials.
The base scenario uses a selling-price assumption of 650 cents and a rounded material allowance of eighty-one cents per portion. The additional-item scenario uses 725 cents and 171 cents. Those are original teaching assumptions, not supplier quotations or sales records. The base material allowance is a deliberately rounded unit illustration related to the menu-production case. It should not be substituted for that case's exact batch total when reconciling its source table.
Original records and the comparison
Subtracting material cost from price gives a base material contribution of 569 cents per portion and an additional-item contribution of 554 cents. The difference is negative fifteen cents. At twenty-four portions, modeled material contribution is 13,656 cents for the base and 13,296 cents for the additional item, a difference of negative 360 cents. A higher selling-price assumption has therefore produced a lower material contribution under these particular quantity and cost assumptions.
The source CSV repeats the calculation at twelve, twenty-four and thirty-six portions. It retains price, unit materials, revenue, material cost and contribution as separate columns. The comparison uses the same portion count for each pair. It does not assume that customers would buy the same number after a price change. Holding the quantity fixed is an explanatory device for the first question, not a forecast of demand or evidence about customer preferences.
An illustrative fixed-cost figure of 9,000 cents is included in every row so readers can see that material contribution and a wider operating result are different concepts. Even subtracting that figure would not establish net profit. The scenario has not defined all labor, tax, premises, equipment, financing or transaction costs. Bennett's revised presentation therefore labels the contribution correctly and places the excluded categories alongside the table rather than after an optimistic conclusion.
Complete original simulated source records · Scroll within the table on a narrow screen.
| Scenario | Portions | Price Cents Per Portion | Material Cents Per Portion | Revenue Cents | Material Cost Cents | Material Contribution Cents | Illustrative Fixed Cost Cents |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base menu | 12 | 650 | 81 | 7800 | 972 | 6828 | 9000 |
| Additional item | 12 | 725 | 171 | 8700 | 2052 | 6648 | 9000 |
| Base menu | 24 | 650 | 81 | 15600 | 1944 | 13656 | 9000 |
| Additional item | 24 | 725 | 171 | 17400 | 4104 | 13296 | 9000 |
| Base menu | 36 | 650 | 81 | 23400 | 2916 | 20484 | 9000 |
| Additional item | 36 | 725 | 171 | 26100 | 6156 | 19944 | 9000 |
Revision, limits and the next question
Colin's feedback also concerns rounding. The eighty-one-cent unit material allowance is an already rounded planning input. Multiplying it by twenty-four gives 1,944 cents, while the related exact batch worksheet sums its rounded ingredient lines to 1,939 cents. The five-cent difference is expected under the two stated calculation bases. Bennett cannot switch between them silently. His source note explains which model each page is using and why a unit illustration should not overwrite a batch reconciliation.
The revision is not a decision to abandon the extra item. It is a decision to stop presenting its higher price as sufficient evidence of an improvement. The concept might lead to a different quantity, a different service requirement or another resource constraint, but those questions need their own assumptions and evidence. The current scenario establishes only the direction and size of the material-contribution difference for matched quantities.
Bennett prepares two visual comparisons from the same six source rows. One shows contribution per portion, and the other shows total contribution at the three quantity levels. Axes and units remain explicit, and the tables stay readable without the charts. The illustrative scenes show a student reviewing a menu and comparing two teaching setups. Neither image is used to display exact price labels or establish how many products a real customer would choose.
For a next exercise, Bennett proposes varying quantity and material cost separately before changing several assumptions at once. He would identify the decision each comparison is intended to inform and retain the original scenario for reference. The completed case is useful because a reader can reproduce its arithmetic, recognize the rounding basis and state the missing evidence. It demonstrates a more careful operating question, not a successful business or a promise that one menu structure will perform better in practice.
In the review meeting, Bennett is asked which decision he can defend now. He can defend asking for more information before adopting the additional item on the strength of its price alone. He cannot defend a forecast of fewer buyers or a claim that the base menu is always preferable. Separating those statements is part of the assessment. A good operating note identifies both the conclusion currently supported and the evidence required before making the next decision.

Complete source package
The downloadable text contains the full case, every original source row and the expected reconciliation. CSV contains the same complete table. These files are learning materials, not business records.